Oily skin that still feels dry: a simple cleansing routine

Shiny by ten. Tight by noon. Both on the same face, on the same day, and nobody warned you that was possible.

The short answer: Oil and water are two separate things in skin. Shine shows you the oil. Tightness is usually about water, and you can be short of it while your forehead gleams. A gentle wash, a light moisturiser straight after, and fewer extras is a sensible place to start.

Why does oily skin feel dry?

Because you can only see one of the two.

In 1997, Louis Fisher, a researcher at Mary Kay, presented a small study at a cosmetic chemists’ meeting, later printed as a preprint in the Journal of Cosmetic Science. He measured 60 women, aged 20 to 60, a few hours after their usual face wash. Oil and moisture were read at four spots: forehead, cheeks, jawline and chin. Oil varied enormously, with a clear T-zone. Moisture barely moved from site to site, and looked similar in women who called themselves oily, dry or normal. How people described their skin followed the oil far more than the moisture.

It’s industry research on small groups, so hold it loosely. It does fit what people notice, though: your eyes read oil, your cheeks read water.

Doesn’t oil protect skin from drying out?

In theory, partly. A 2025 review in Bioengineering describes sebum as a water-repelling film that slows water loss. But the skin’s actual barrier is built from different fats: ceramides, fatty acids and cholesterol, packed like mortar between cells. Sebum is mostly triglycerides, wax esters and squalene. A fluid film on the surface, not the wall.

Fisher’s follow-up pointed the same way. In 20 women, sebum climbed through the day while moisture on the untreated side stayed flat, and the two didn’t track each other. His conclusion was that sebum may not defend against dehydration.

So “I’m oily, so I can’t be dry” is an assumption, not a rule.

Is your whole face the same skin?

Almost never. The T-zone pattern showed up in both of Fisher’s studies: forehead and chin ran oilier, cheeks and jawline less so. The Bioengineering review puts roughly a quarter of adults in the oily group and about half in mixed skin, with large differences from one area to another. So a wash that suits your forehead can be too much for your cheeks. Judge a wash by what your cheeks and jawline say an hour after it, not by how matte your forehead looks.

Does washing too often make oily skin oilier?

Not necessarily the way you’ve heard. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) says many people with oily skin believe they need a strong wash to dry it out, and that a harsh one can irritate skin and trigger more oil. Fair. But harshness and frequency are different questions.

In a 2006 randomised trial in Pediatric Dermatology, men with mild to moderate acne washed once, twice or four times a day for six weeks. Blackheads improved in the twice-a-day group, while the once-a-day group got worse. The authors concluded that too much washing may be less to blame than people assume. Separately, a Thai master’s thesis followed 59 acne patients washing one, two or three times a day and found no difference in sebum between the groups.

Both are small, both are about acne, and neither measured how skin felt. Still, harshness looks like a bigger factor than how often you wash.

What does this look like in a real day?

Picture Imran. He’s invented, a composite, not a customer. He walks from a humid Karachi street into an air-conditioned office. By ten his forehead shines. By two his cheeks are pulling. He decides he’s too oily for moisturiser, washes at lunch with a strong foaming gel, and blots. By evening it’s worse, and he’s out another bottle of gel.

Air conditioning plays a part. A paper on facial skin moisture in adult women notes that indoor humidity drops during heating and cooling, which increases water loss from skin. In Imran’s case the shine and the pulling may have different causes.

What’s a simple routine for oily skin that feels dry?

Three steps, not twelve.

Wash morning and evening, and after exercise. That’s the AAD’s advice for oily skin, using a daily foaming wash. It also says to avoid oil-based or alcohol-based cleansers, which can irritate.

Moisturise right after, even though you’re oily. The AAD says to apply moisturiser daily and to choose oil-free, non-comedogenic products. In Fisher’s second study, a light moisturiser raised measured moisture by 31% two hours later, and it was still 14% above baseline six hours on, whatever the person’s oil level. Small study, but it points to a light moisturiser, not a heavy one.

Blot, don’t rewash. Midday shine isn’t a cleansing emergency. The AAD suggests blotting paper over repeated touching.

That’s the whole routine. Make the change in one go, then give it a couple of weeks before you judge it. One morning proves nothing.

Back to Imran. He keeps the shine and drops the lunchtime wash. At two o’clock he stops asking “is it oily?”, because it will be, and asks “do my cheeks feel pulled?” His eyes can’t answer that one, so he checks an hour after washing.

When is it not dehydration?

Sometimes shiny skin with flaking is something else. The AAD says seborrheic dermatitis often appears on oily areas, such as between and under the eyebrows, the sides of the nose and around the mouth, and that skin there tends to be oily in some spots and dry in others. If you have red, scaly or itchy patches in those places, or anything that stings, cracks or keeps coming back, that’s a question for a dermatologist, not a cleanser.

Where does Mugtea fit?

Mugtea is meant for step one. It starts as a paste, turns to cream with a little water, then opens into a foam. Its cleansing base is SCI-led, a coconut-derived isethionate, with microfine kaolin to pick up excess oil, glycerin and panthenol for how skin feels afterwards, and salicylic acid, an exfoliating ingredient. It’s formulated for normal, oily and combination skin, aims to be mild, and is meant to clean oily skin without leaving it feeling pulled.

A few limits. Mugtea is a cleanser, not a moisturiser, so step two is still yours. Salicylic acid can bother some skin, so patch test on your jawline first, use the daily wash only for a week, and stop if your skin objects. If your skin is reactive, or you’re on a prescription treatment, ask your dermatologist first. On an evening when you have time, you can leave it on for 2 minutes as a pack, then rinse.

Shiny and tight at once isn’t a verdict on your skin type.

Mugtea is available now. Shop Mugtea →

Where does your face feel it first, cheeks or around the mouth? And does it hit right after washing, or by mid-afternoon? Tell us.